/fim/ - FiM

A place for all things FiM

Mode: Reply
Name
Subject
Message

Max message length: 4096

Files

Max file size: 4.00 MB

Max files: 3

E-mail
Password

(used to delete files and postings)

Misc

Remember to follow the rules


(253.04 KB 2718x3650 SP TitleSpecialColor.png)
Anonymous 09/29/2021 (Wed) 00:38:08 No. 3544
I was told in the /mlp/ Tempo thread that you guys might like to have a thread about this. I have been producing a document called the "Summa Pona" outlining a framework that, when combined with the show, can become a religion that I've dubbed 'Ponism'. The book is not a central religious text however, as it emphasizes that the only thing worthy of worship is FiM and it's spirit which I refer to as 'Pona'. It's not yet complete, but it will be by the time that the /mare/con panel takes place (If /mare/con holds on till January that is) and that panel will largely be an overview of the text itself, the development and research process that went into it, and if time allows a Q&A will be hosted in the thread. While the Summa is not ready to be shared, I do want to share the planning document I used which can provide the basic ideas behind the project in outline form. https://docs.google.com/document/d/1yNnmjJljEyTnTM4ZGTFQayf4S3Ut5kNWaLF9CXzEL1U/edit?usp=sharing /)
>>3641 Any prescriptive rule is dogmatic, unfortunately. To truly communicate such a concept you need to either know the person well enough to predict how your lessons are going to come off, or you need to 'circum-ambulate' the topic, approaching it from many different angles, applying it to as many varied situations as possible, so as to triangulate a center point from so many tangents. This is necessary because people will always hear what they want to hear, and look for how your points (or the show's points) reinforce or oppose that. If they take an interest, whether positive or negative, in these points, you can lead them along through the maze of misinterpretation by showing them a thousand ways they answer questions that were previously left blank. If you can't, then well, you need to work on your own understanding too. For example, friendship and harmony is easy to tout as the 'light side', where everybody is working together to better themselves and the world, and people without it are the bad guys. But what about friendship and harmony among bandits, slavers, oil conglomerates? From the limited perspective of 'the good guys', the first instinct is to say "in these situations friendship and harmony are bad, because they create real personal danger to us", and relative to the conflict of good guys vs. bad guys, maybe that's correct. So friendship and harmony, to be useful at all, must be applied in a more specific, nuanced way, otherwise the principle *becomes* dogmatic, and fuel the us-vs-them mindset. It must be applied irrespective of boundaries and borderlines. Well, what if your compromise with the bandits and oil barons means that shit is still gonna suck? Bandits will still steal, oil barons will still pollute the world. Friendship means loving them and forgiving them as they do it - but how can we be friends with people who hurt us? Now you must find a deeper, more complex friendship and harmony; you must learn to love and forgive *yourself*, because yourself will always fight back against injustices. You are interrupting that bandit or that oil baron's entire life by enforcing justice; you must be able to feel their pain even as you inflict it, if you ever hope to understand them and reach harmony with them. On an even more abstract level, your actions must be in harmony with your soul. If you aren't friends with your deepest self, then the only relationship there can be is *conflict* with your deeper self. Conflict means inefficiency, it means both sides expending energy in a fight, that could otherwise be used to further a common goal. You cannot be an effective person if you have great levels of internal conflict. Furthermore, any contribution you make to an external harmony will be marred by your own internal dissonance, like a single instrument in an orchestra slightly out of tune. And so on. Harmony is virtuous, but there is no virtue so pure as to be uncorrupted by the bluntness of language.
>>3714 Dogma is dangerous when perpetuated without relation to the original consequences that created the dogma. When the source of the dogma and it's perpetuator is the immortal God-Princess who watches the country millenium after millennium, dogma will never deteriorate because she will always will always keep it in tune with reality and her authority will ensure the agreement on any change.
>>3544 Why would we ever need a religion? Isn't it enough that a person likes the snow and maybe tries to apply something he learned with it IRL, why is there a need to organize this pure passion into some sort of cult? (I'm not trying to offend you OP, but that's just how i see all attempts to create a non-ironic pony religion)
>>4460 Could just be >for fun
>>4460 To me, the very concept of religion seems particularly alien to pony.
>>4460 >Isn't it enough that a person likes the snow >>2295
>>4461 Well sure, i was talking about unironic stuff. If it's all just a joke i have no problems with it
>>4460 I don't view it as a a function of people's need for a pony religion so much as a want for it. Before I ever started this project I saw that there were a number of anons out there who held beliefs centered around ponies such as the idea of Equestria being their afterlife. Part of the Summa is an attempt to reconcile that into a cohesive religion that people can reasonable practice. I also wanted to try my hand at this when I was personally dissatisfied with Celestianism, which was an earlier attempt at a pony religion made by an /mlp/ group.
>>4562 Call me a schizo if you want. But it seems to me that every entity is drawn toward what best reflects its own truest nature. I can only reduce corruptive influences and hope that mine resembles what was depicted in the show. I'm not seeing what benefit imitating religion would add.
wtf is that?

Delete
Report