>to avoid AiE shit Oh boy here we go.

>>23586 Don't tempt fate

>>23583 >(You) choose >no memories- not (You) here's your (You) i guess

>>23593 It's a hypothetical question calm down

I choose OP getting gassed for being a faggot.

>>23583 >you'll lose all your memories I pick who the fuck cares. I'm dead in any way that matters. Let's go with Discord and S3, after he hooks up with Fluttershy.

>>23593 How is it even that hard to understand, you'd still have the same soul, and you're also picking what you think you'd want your future life to be. >>23603 I just wanted a milf thread, I didn't expect this crap. >>23609 >Let's go with Discord and S3, after he hooks up with Fluttershy. That's just fucked.

>>23615 >you'd still have the same soul No, I wouldn't. Everything you have done, everything you have seen, is all wiped away. The soul becomes a blank slate. What you're asking is "Who do you want to be the mother of this complete stranger?".

>>23639 The way I see it, experiences still leave a mark on the soul, even if you can't remember them; I suppose I should have been more clear when I made the thread, but I was more concerned about preventing AiE autism.

I would be born to whatever random parent would show me love and care and teach me to be the best pony I can be, beyond that I don't care because that's future me's problem. That dude's gonna have pony problems, I'm not gonna be able to relate to him at all.

>>23641 >You don't know why, but you keep calling Starlight Glimmer "Poochie", and you keep trying to turn her inside-out.

>>23645 Pony problems are People problems

>>23583 >lose all your memories Do I know what Equestria is? Do I, a human forgetting I love ponies, want a pony to be my mother? Do I know what a pony is?

>>23658 >Do I, a human forgetting I love ponies, want a pony to be my mother? see >>23641 >>23647

>>23615 >I j-just wanted a milf thread >blatantly puts his TFtranny fantasies in the OP No, you just wanted to use momhorses as a plug-in for your degeneracy. Fuck off.

>>23681 >tranny tranny tranny yep, it's nhnb

>>23583 Oh I don't know if I could choose. They all seem like super sweet mothers to have. Okay, either Twilight Velvet, Windy Whistles or Pear Butter. I am less sure how I would look brought up by flutter, pinka or rary-mom.

>>23583 I guess it'd be a mom pony that isn't one of the ones shown here so I'd have a chance with any of the mane6, to avoid incest unless you're into that.

>>23583 You could have just ended your post at the first question mark and it could have been a decent prompt.

>>23583 Thanks to this story https://www.fimfiction.net/story/574794/anon-annie I want Applejack to be my pony mom.

>>23681 Is it wrong to make your own headcanon and say that Creamheart is canon? She does have an episode soo. >>23817 Ya I messed it up big time, I reported it and asked the mods to delete since I can't but oh well, was gonna remake it without a prompt at all, maybe it'll just fix itself you know?

>choose pear butter >date my sisters

>>24332 Do you have to read the one that comes before it first?

>>23583 >Pear Butter or Cloudy Quartz No way, I don't want to live in a farm >Cookie Crumbles I like Rarity and Sweetie Belle, but it would suck to have them as my sisters >Mrs. Shy It could work >Windy Whistles It would be really cool to have Rainbow Dash as my sister >Twilight Velvet She's the one I would choose because Twily is my waifu and it would be nice to grow up with her and her brother. But since I wouldn't be able to marry Twily, I would have to marry Trixie instead (Starlight would work too)

>>23583 deciding this, you not only need to take into account the parent, but the siblings and living conditions you'd have as well >Twilight Velvet Pros: >99.999% chance of being born a unicorn >high chance of being born a unicorn with at the very least notable levels of magic power >born in Canterlot >good siblings Cons: >two very high achieving siblings so a lot of potential pressure >Windy Whistles Pros: >born a pegasus >born in Cloudsdale >Dash as a sister would push you to be just as good as her so she'd have good competition -Your parents would love and support you no matter what Cons: >Dash would almost certainly surpass you in every way so get used to that silver medal >parental support may warp into feeling like they're mocking you if you see yourself as a failure >Cookie Crumbles Pros: >high chance of being born a unicorn >you'd have two sisters, one generous and one loving Cons: >you'd probably end up in Rarity's shadow >would have to put up with Rarity pretending to be posh despite your parents having accents like they're from Pony Minnesota >Mrs. Shy (did we ever learn what the fuck her name is?) Pros: >Born a pegasus >Kind and loving family Cons: >Zephyr as a brother >Zephyr as a brother >Zephyr as a brother >Cloudy Quartz Pros: >Working on a rock farm you'd probably end up as one of the strongest earth ponies in Equestria >Pinkie as a sister Cons: >Born a mud pony >Born in the middle of buttfuck nowhere >Pony amish family >High chance of being dead inside like the three sisters that aren't Pinkie >Pear Butter Pros: >Born into the Apple Family >Incest? Cons: >Incest? >Parents die when you're young Twilight Velvet is probably the safest bet in terms of getting a quality life, Cookie Crumbles could be nice to mess with Rarity, the Shy family is tempting if only to give Fluttershy a brother that isn't Zephyr and Pear Butter is appealing as the Apple Family is top comfy

>>24464 >Zephyr as a brother >Zephyr as a brother >Zephyr as a brother This would also mean that dissapointing your parents is borderline impossible Rolling for not dissapointing new Shy parents

>>24468 The trick is that you have to bully Zephyr into not being a degenerate

>>24470 this is why OP is a degenerate tranny fag for saying you get no memories if you have no memories of what Zephyr becomes how are you supposed to be enough of yourself to motivate yourself to bully him into being better, with no memories you run the risk of becoming as meek as the rest of your family and putting up with his degeneracy

>>24472 I am OP, but I don't disagree with bullying Zephyr

>>24475 good luck with that when you have no memories >I would just naturally grow up to not like his- no, no you would not, that's the point of keeping your memories

>>24476 If you do not believe in your heart of hearts that your soul would bully Zephyr Breeze (If Zephyr has a middle name then why doesn't Fluttershy?) then that's your own problem.

>>24479 considering that I was planning to post some new green to the Anonstallion thread before /mlp/ died this is tempting me to at least write a one shot for here I got stuff to do today, so when I get back, I might write it then

>>24491 If it involves a young Anon bullying Zephyr Breeze and also has Mrs. Shy in it, then consider me hyped for it

>>23664 >see: [example and explanation] Not only are you erased, but you also drive an innocent foal completely insane. This just keeps getting better and better.

>>24544 Why would they go insane, do you got some demons you gotta tell us about Anon?

>>24551 They would have a lifetime's worth of "marks on their soul", but none of the memories to give it any context. Since we're talking about bronies, here, at the very least we'll have them hating certain ponies for no discernible reason and/or irrational infatuation with ponies they have never met. (possibly ones that don't even exist)

>>24574 >hating ponies WHAT?!

>>24574 >They would have a lifetime's worth of "marks on their soul" All of which they'd have their whole life to get over, and it's not like irrational phobias don't exist, if you want, you could maybe have Flashbacks/dreams about your past however those end up being depicted (if you want that to even be a thing in your fantasy) >at the very least we'll have them hating certain ponies for no discernible reason Hating people for no reason and getting over it later isn't suuuper uncommon as is >or irrational infatuation with ponies they have never met. That would probably end up being a longing for something more until you met them, at which point your soul might still love them so that opens up a can of worms, and possibilties >(possibly ones that don't even exist) I don't even think this one would apply at all, you'd get over that fast.